How Accurate Are Online Remodel Cost Estimators?
What Spokane & North Idaho Homeowners Need to Know Before Trusting That Number
Let’s be honest — we’ve all done it.
You’re thinking about remodeling your kitchen or adding a bathroom, and you punch a few numbers into an online cost estimator. Thirty seconds later, it spits out a number that feels… suspiciously low. Or maybe shockingly high.
So how accurate are those remodeling cost calculators?
At The Building Company, we work with homeowners across Spokane, Coeur d’Alene, and North Idaho who are trying to budget responsibly. Online tools can be a helpful starting point — but they’re often misleading when it comes to real-world pricing and scope.
Here’s what you need to know before you trust that number.
🧮 Online Estimators Are Averages — Not Reality
Most cost calculators are built on national or regional averages. They pull data from a wide range of project types, finishes, and market conditions. But here’s the problem:
- There’s no “average” kitchen in Spokane. Or CDA. Or Sandpoint.
- There are 1,400-square-foot ranchers and 5,000-square-foot lakeside homes — and everything in between.
- That’s why many calculators are off by 20–60% (or more) when compared to actual local bids
🛠️ What They Often Leave Out
Even the better calculators can miss or misrepresent key cost factors, like:
- Permits — Different jurisdictions (Spokane vs. Hayden vs. Liberty Lake) have different fees and requirements
- Design — Custom design work isn’t usually included
- Demo & prep — What’s behind the walls matters (plumbing, wiring, asbestos, rot)
- Material quality — There’s a world of difference between stock cabinets and custom millwork
- Site conditions — Sloped lots, narrow access, or older foundations all affect cost
Plus, online tools rarely account for construction logistics like dust protection, project management, or warranty service.
🏡 Local Market Pricing Varies Widely — and Changes Fast
Here in the Inland Northwest, remodeling costs have a huge range — not because contractors are inconsistent, but because material choices, labor complexity, and layout decisions vary so much.
For example:
- Laminate countertops might cost $25–$45/sf installed
- Quartz? $65–$100+
- Handmade tile backsplash? Easily $150/sf with labor
That’s not even touching appliance packages, flooring, or structural changes.
And while some materials have stabilized in 2024, supply chains, fuel prices, and subcontractor availability all continue to affect bids.
🤝 What You Can Use Cost Estimators For
To be fair, we don’t hate cost calculators. They can help you:
- Compare basic cost ranges between project types
- Begin thinking in “buckets” (e.g., $50K vs. $150K projects)
- Ask better questions when meeting with a contractor
Just don’t use them as a quote — or a commitment.
💬 What We Do Instead
At The Building Company, we offer a clear, step-by-step process that takes you from idea to investment clarity without wasting time:
- Initial Consultation — We walk your space and listen
- Scope + Goals Alignment — We help define what you’re really after
- Budget Development — We create realistic ranges based on real projects and actual local costs
- Design + Estimate — Our team or design partners develop plans that match your goals and budget
- Build Agreement — Only when you’re confident in the plan, pricing, and timeline do we proceed
This approach is why so many of our Spokane-area clients stay on budget — even in today’s market.
Want Real Numbers for Your Real Project?
Let’s ditch the guesswork and have a real conversation about your goals, your home, and what’s possible.
📱 Call or text: 509-890-0222
📧 Email: info@pnwbuild.com
The Building Company is a proud member of the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) and the National Association of the Remodeling Industry (NARI), reflecting our commitment to professionalism, transparency, and lasting value.
